The Town of Huntington’s 2027 budget has taken an unexpected turn in recent weeks, with a proposed property tax levy increase of more than 18% meeting a last-minute effort to bring that increase within the state tax cap. Questions about the accuracy of the revised budget figures persist, while many residents are left shaking their heads at what this all means.
The confusion unfolded during the final week before the town’s budget deadline, leaving residents with questions about what was approved and what wasn’t, and how the final budget will affect taxpayers.
Here’s a look at how the process unfolded and where things stand.
A budget process that began in June
The town’s budget process began in June 2026 and continued through the summer and fall, with department reviews, budget workshops, public hearings and other opportunities for town board members to discuss spending and make recommendations before submitting an official budget plan.
At a November 20 “emergency” meeting, Supervisor Ed Smyth said that the process had been underway for months and that all town board members had been invited to participate in that process. The town also prepared a budget showing what it would take – including the level of cuts necessary – to remain under the state tax cap, he said.
According to Smyth, budget workshops took place in August and September. While board members reviewed the results and offered suggestions, no formal resolutions came out of those workshops, he said. The preliminary budget was presented to the board on October 2, and Smyth said trustees had another 30 days to review it and raise questions. He added that the comptroller’s office and town staff were available to answer questions during that period.
In his October letter to board members accompanying the preliminary budget, Smyth said rising expenses and state mandates had made it increasingly difficult for the town to stay within the state tax cap without reducing services.
He cited several major cost increases, including expenses related to early 2026 snowstorms, higher state retirement and health insurance costs, increased refuse collection fees, workers’ compensation, debt service and wage increases tied to collective bargaining agreements.
Smyth said the proposed budget would maintain town services and staffing while reducing the town’s reliance on reserves – currently $70 million – to cover recurring expenses.
That proposed budget, however, would greatly exceed the state tax cap.
The proposed 18.39% tax levy increase
New York’s property tax cap limits how much a municipality can increase its property tax levy each year. For Huntington’s 2027 budget, the allowable increase was 2.68%.
The proposed 2027 budget would have increased the town’s tax levy from $143,543,987 in 2026 to $169,941,874 in 2027, an increase of 18.39%.
That’s approximately $22.55 million above the $147,390,966 levy permitted under the tax cap.
Smyth argued that staying within the cap would require cuts to town programs, services and staffing. In his letter, he said the proposed budget was designed to preserve services while addressing rising costs and maintaining the town’s long-term financial stability.
The town board had previously authorized the town to exceed the tax cap through a local law, but that authorization did not require the board to adopt a budget above the cap.
39 amendments introduced on November 17
The debate took a significant turn at a November 17 town board meeting – at which the board was meant to adopt the proposed budget – when Councilwoman Theresa Mari introduced 39 amendments to the proposed budget. She said the changes were intended to bring the tax levy increase within the state cap without eliminating jobs or cutting services.
Changes highlighted in Mari’s November 17 press release include:
- Delaying 21 vacant positions: Filling the positions in the general fund would be delayed for nine months, with estimated savings of approximately $2 million. Mari said no employees would be laid off and no positions eliminated.
- Recognizing federal funding: The budget would include $3.5 million in federal Community Project Funding secured by Congressman Nick LaLota.
- Reducing outside legal expenses: The town attorney’s outside counsel budget would remain at the 2026 forecast of $950,000 rather than increase to $1.25 million.
- Adjusting revenue and spending estimates: Several figures were revised to align more closely with the town’s 2025 actuals and 2026 forecasts.
The board approved all 39 amendments by a vote of 3-0, with Mari, Councilman Dave Bennardo and Councilwoman Jennifer Hebert voting in favor. Smyth and Councilwoman Brooke Lupinacci abstained, citing insufficient time to review the amendments before the meeting.
The vote to approve the amended budget as a whole, however, failed 2-3. Mari and Bennardo voted in favor, while Smyth, Hebert and Lupinacci voted against it.
Mari issued a press release after the meeting declaring that the amendments had kept the budget within the state tax cap. She also posted videos on social media explaining the changes and emphasizing that they would avoid layoffs and service cuts.
Hebert later explained her vote in a Facebook video. She said she had attended budget workshops and repeatedly suggested ways to reduce spending, but felt her recommendations were not considered. She supported Mari’s amendments in good faith, she said, because she wanted to honor her commitment to residents and taxpayers. However, she voted against the overall budget, saying, “There was no way I could support a budget process that was so completely flawed and disrespectful. A process that included no discussions, no teamwork and no accountability.”
Questions about the amendments lead to special meetings
In the days following the November 17 meeting, questions emerged about some of the revised revenue and expense projections.
Smyth raised concerns about whether certain revenue estimates were realistic. One example involved projected income from refuse tipping fees at the Reworld facility, formerly known as Covanta. He questioned whether the town could count the full amount being projected, since Huntington shares some of that revenue with Smithtown and private waste haulers are not required to use the facility.
At the November 20 special meeting, Smyth said he had received Mari’s proposed amendments little more than an hour before the November 17 meeting. He said he and the comptroller’s office had spent the following days reviewing the changes and checking them against governmental reporting standards.
Smyth invited Town Comptroller Jonas Wagner to address the board. Wagner said the short time available to review the amendments had made the work challenging and raised concerns about whether some of the changes were valid as written.
The town would need to work with the comptroller’s office to determine how to address the issues, Smyth said. He also warned that the town might have to use reserve funds to make up for revenue that the amended budget projected but that might not materialize. He said the budget had to be submitted by the November 20 deadline and that the town needed to move forward so tax bills could be prepared.
The November 20 special meetings had been called specifically to consider rescinding some of the amendments approved on November 17. The meeting agenda included resolutions to rescind eight amendments and revise another.
Neither the 2pm meeting nor the follow-up meeting at 6pm had enough town board members present to conduct business, therefore no votes were taken.
Bennardo was out of town and had informed the board of his prior commitment before the special meetings were scheduled. Mari submitted a letter objecting to the short notice, arguing that the meeting had not been properly called under state law, which requires written notice to board members. Lupinacci also submitted a statement saying she had concerns about the legality of proceeding with the meeting given the notice provided. She said she did not believe it was legally prudent to participate.
Only Smyth and Hebert attended the meetings.
During the 6pm meeting, Smyth again discussed the months-long budget process, saying board members had been given opportunities to participate, review the numbers and make recommendations. He said the town had demonstrated what staying under the tax cap would require and that the workshops had provided an opportunity to consider those potential cuts.
Hebert offered a different perspective, saying she had asked for a budget that fell between the original proposal, with its 18% tax levy increase, and one that was closer to the tax cap and would not significantly harm town services. She said she wanted a realistic budget that was fair to taxpayers and that she had repeatedly asked for a more transparent process.
What happens next?
Under New York State town law, towns must adopt their annual budgets by November 20. If a town board does not adopt a budget by that date, the preliminary budget, including any changes made by the board, becomes the budget for the coming fiscal year.
Because the town board did not adopt the amended budget as a whole and did not take further action at the November 20 special meetings, the amendments approved on November 17 remained the latest changes made by the board before the deadline.
The town said it planned to submit the proposed budget incorporating Mari’s 39 approved amendments to the state, along with explanations acknowledging the issues that had been identified. That submission does not mean the board voted to adopt the full amended budget; that vote had failed earlier in the week.
For residents, the central questions remain whether – with the budget and amendments now submitted – the revised revenue and spending projections will hold up, if the town will ultimately remain within the 2.68% tax cap, and how the 2027 spending plan will affect town services and property taxpayers.
Don’t miss a story
Get the latest news delivered to your inbox.